Transformation Care for Winterbourne View Hospital
Abstract
The cases of the oppression and discrimination of people with mental health disorders and autism have become a common occurrence causing the need for the transformation. The research aims to test for the response transformation care at winterbourne view hospital which is associated with health care services for the mentally disable and people with autism. They aimed to improve the services provided to the patients to ensure that the services provided to the patient with mental disability and autism patient-centred. The research involved qualitative research where questionnaires were presented and interviews to the patient health workers and visitors. The results indicated among the challenges for the implementation were poor and inadequate staffing of the hospitals, poor leadership among other factors, and cases of oppression on the patients by the health worker which translated to a poor culture of the hospital. Cases reported indicated that the oppression and discrimination involved the beating and hindering visitation of the patients by their relatives. In conclusion, the main cause of all the issues at winterbourne view hospital is associated with lack of management which translated to poor staffing and poor-quality services to the service user. This has led to the recommendation on the improvement and adoption of high-performing managers in the management to ensure good project management in implementing the policies. Also, pry preparation for the program before implementation to ensure that the success of the program.
Executive summary
- The lack of leadership in the winterbourne view hospital was one of the big failures that lead to the failure of the hospital to implement the transformation policy. The bill required the facility to adopt the patient-centered where the services to the patient are prioritized.
- The sensitivity of the abusive case created an avenue for change where the patient care and protection were changed by the service provider. The health care workers who were to give the services to the patient were the ones offering abusive services to them.
- The facilities could not take the reformation needed to have developed structure and specialists that are to need from the transformation of the health care services. The change to patient-oriented services provision creates new opportunities that require specialists.
- The use of abusive means created a wider picture as it involved going against the human right that restricts the use of force on patients, this case was representative of what patients go through in the other care providing facilities.
- The human right policy grants all the citizen the same right to be free from oppression despite their condition making the case on winterbourne an abstraction of human rights. The abusive means used in the hospital by the health caregiver exposes them to the threat of closure for abusing patient.
- Implementation of the transformation requires the hospitals to have:
- Infrastructures for use by the patient.
- Good management,
- Trained personnel for the arising opportunities.
- Qualified and high performing staffs.
Recommendation.
The policy must put into place all the measures essential for the transformation where all the funds required are provided to avoid the delay in the implementation.
The policy should also provide specialized health care officials to cater to the need arising from the transformation starting from the training institution for future references.
Table of content
Table of Contents
Chapter 1 Introduction.
Transformation of health care is an attempt to rearrange the delivery system to the patient as the receiver of the services from the services providers who are the health care officers. The program aims to have the services delivery change to assume a customer-centric focus, where they are more concerned about the services they provide to the patients. The transformation requires health care to acquire a leadership that can take the risk in change the system through, first changing from the traditional values by involving non-traditional partners. Secondly, directing the improvement of health care services to be high quality and affordable to the clients to enhance the delivery of the services. The creation of a strategic identity where all the efforts in the development strategies are directed towards achieving the goal of transformation achieved through good communication across the facilities. Also maintaining and building trust in the health care can be achieved through ensuring they change from facilities where data is placed for safekeeping to a centre where confidence in the system is built through the providers and the protocols among other commitments to changing the system.
The transformation of health care has led to the rethinking of the roles of most health care professionals as the market is shifting and change becomes inevitable. In response to change the development of the Affordable Care Act of 2010 provides the facilities with the entity, where the development of new roles is based in response to change. New roles and opportunities for the health care officials will be used in the attempt to increasing the quality of the services provided to the patient as the system is transformed into a patient-centred system. The transformation in health care is deeply dependent on the government policies in place to control the change as well as the leadership in place and their response to change. The transformation has so far led to the development and evaluation of the high quality and technologically developed hospitals, the care for chronically ill-being coordinated with that of the elderly in an attempt to improve the services to the customer among other achievements.
The transformation was driven by winterbourne's view of hospital cases where discrimination that the patient was experiencing was too high to be ignored. The closure of the hospital was to ensure that services are provided to the patient in an environment free from all forms of oppression by the health workers. In doing so the program was to change the existing culture where the value of the patient was degraded through the use of abusive words and phrases indicating the existing system required to be changed for the betterment of the services. The long period that the patients were staying at the hospital was the cause of the congestion that was reported in the hospital and was the cause for the call for changing the hospitals to have patients served at home to reduce those cases.
The quality of health services given at winterbourne view hospital was considered poor and thus unhealthy to the extent where the prescription was done without cases of diagnosis. The cases reported on a patient with the mental disorder being given anti-psychotic and antidepressant drugs without the following and administering the prescription ware numerous. Similarly, cases of restricted visitation of the patient by their family members created an environment where the degradation of the services provided to the patient as no observation was done on the quality of service they were offering. The degradation of the services was the failure of the management to meet its goal in the management of resources, but the failure of the hospital to have management was the cause of the failures as they lacked someone to monitor the progress of theirs resources, staffs, and health workers. The transformation aims to improve the quality of the health care services to the patients in an attempt to change it to patient-centred.
1.1 Literature review
The previous research on transformation forms a key aspect to the program on Winterbourne view hospital. According to, Taylor, et al. (2017). On the effects of transformation of health care and consideration of the safety and effects the policies of transformation will have on [people with disabilities. The policy on the transformation lacks investment in the community where despite the lack of knowledge and clinical complexity that is associated with tackling and taking care of patients under the intellectual mental disorder (Taylor, et al. 2017). This patient usually displays offending and non-offending behaviours that usually have them restrained under the health act but the transformation is ensuring that most of the patients are discharged with reduced cases of readmission. The policy ensures the provision of the services to the patient by the community to reduce the lengthy stay in the hospitals as well as strengthen community service to individuals with intellectual disabilities (Newman, et al. 2018). The effect of the policy is the failure to strengthen the community service as most of these services require specialized personnel to tackle them. The discharge of this intellectually disabled character is exposing the community to the risk of damage of properties, sexual offenses, use of violence, and the property damage associated by the intellectually disabled people.
According to, Marshall-Tate, Chaplin, & McCarthy, (2017). The cases of an individual with intellectual disability and autism are common as the cost of implication where the training of the health care workers was not meet. The issue was accelerated by poor staff training leading to the acquisition of little knowledge to tackle the patients challenging behaviours and the challenge of service commissioning where the health workers were separated from social workers. (Fylan, et al. 2019) The admission of the patient with mental health issues indicated that they have additional mental health needs that required special attention to reducing the case of mental breakdown. The development of autism policy and TS policy was aimed at the betterment of the services provided to this patient in the transformation program where all the facilities were to adapt to a new style of a hospital. The case of winterbourne on restraining and offensive practice were all working against the policies. Despite this, the TS policy aimed to reduce the bed for autism and intellectually challenged disabilities patients despite the challenges which advocate for increased bed (Alderwick, & Ham, 2017). The support from the UK government of twenty-five million dollars helped in pushing the process of disposing the patient into the community where the special services they required were not available.
According to Washington, Bull, & Woodrow, (2019). The transition of intellectual disability patients from the health institution to community-based care should be supported through adequate allocation of resources to support the program. The WHO, 2011 advocates for the support of the program through service infrastructure through the development of new services as the transformation calls for the development of new roles for the health care staff. Due to the development at Winterbourne view hospital, the England government and the department of health (DH) come up with guidance on supporting people who are discharged from the program with the local community care. In the development of the transformation program, the processes that used to take a long period like admission, assessment, and the procedural treatment measure were converted to the modern form. The reduction of the patient with autism being reduced to take thirty-three months in Scotland unlike the four years and three months taken in England.
According to Barnoux, (2019). The barriers to the transformation program are the aspect of poor staffing where the new programs lead to new roles, inadequate staffing of the hospitals, and ineffective teamwork affecting the effectiveness of the program. The barriers are the cause for the prolonged stay for the patients in the hospitals as the care unit needs more time to handle all the patients as the service users, considering the cases to prioritize on, provision of high-quality services to the users, and other difficulties. In the call for transformation and the health care can adopt a multi-agency approach where the teams in the health care unit should be locally accessible for the patient, effective in their service delivery thus high performance and should adopt a patient-centred approach in offering the services to the users. With the change in the health care unit the need for specialists, the community will need high quality and specialized services for the mentally challenged and autistic patients to be able to tackle them.
Chapter 2 Results/findingsThe research incorporated qualitative research and analysis. From the research, the winterbourne view hospital was conducted through questionaries and interviews it was conducted on doctors, staff, nurses, and other health care staff, patients, and their relatives.
|
Number of visitations |
Quality of services |
Time is taken for medication |
Cases of discrimination |
Patient |
3 |
Poor |
4 years |
|
Relatives |
3 |
Poor |
4years |
17 |
Questionnaire for patients and relatives
|
Availability of managers |
Adequately staffing |
Cases of used force |
Doctors |
No |
No |
Occasionally |
Nurses |
No |
No |
Occasionally |
The result from the worker's questionnaire
The case of lack of manager was reported in all cases of the questionnaire with cases of health care officers using force being reported from the patient and their relatives. The visitations were restricted and reduced to at least three times for the patients despite the cases of using force on them increased. The time of the patients to take medication was increased to four years and some more than four years.
Chapter 3 Discussion.The ideology affecting the transformation of winterbourne are issues associated with inadequate staffing and lack of resources to implement the current transformation measures in place. The situation is under the fact that to ensure that the hospital bed for the patients with autism and mental disability is reduced the England government needs to develop a strategy. (Taylor, 2019). The strategy needs to have the community developed through the investment in the community to enable them to be able to handle the patients as they need special care. The program needs to ensure the reduction of the beds for the patient is achieved through the community being able to take care of the patient by equipping them with specialist required by the transformation (Williams, et al. 2019. Despite the effort made in achieving the change the report on the National Audit Office claimed that the funds for ensuring the measures in place are made have not yet to be released making the program dormant (Taylor, et al. 2017). This makes the main cause to be the lack of infrastructures to enable them to transform to the next level of reducing the beds in the facilities. Due to the high requirement of the specialist the by the programs calls for more health care personnel’s as the program creates new positions for them as it transforms the health care to be patient-centered.
The change requires the management to take part in the coordination of the resources to achieve the change and gain the benefit required. The lack of a management body in the winterbourne view hospital acted as one of the key failures of the hospital in the implementation of the program.( Piroozi, et al.2017). The work of the management is to control the activities in an association and ensure that quality services are provided to the customers to their satisfaction. The lack of a manager in the hospital was the cause of the poor-quality service provision where the staffs had no one to check on the quality of services they were offering to the patients (Fyson, & Patterson, 2020). The aspect of the patient being patients being abused is the failure of the management to have the culture of abuse extracted from the hospital and have the culture of the patient protection from abuse in place. To ensure that the system does not affect the patient’s existence in the hospital the management should have developed a good culture earlier and prevent the development of a poor culture where the patients are oppressed by the health care workers (Okuyama, Galvao, & Silva, 2018). The lack of adequate measures to ensure that the services provided to the patients are increased especially the ones with disability due to poor management has led to more cases bring attention to the program and calling for the services to be patient-centred. In the protection measure, the human rights call for the measure where the articles restrict the use of force and calls for the adoption of appropriate measures to achieve control rather than the use of force (Joyce, 2020). In return, the adopted measure should use proportionate force but only when appropriate to address the problem concerned.
The patients reported the calls for help that they made where the excessive force and restriction to visitation were initiated but the management failed to attend to them. The failure of the management and others, that is, the commissioners, regulators, and other bodies associated with the control of the activities of the facility in attaining its goal of rehabilitation (Chester, et al. 2018). The management is responsible for most of the activity in this hospital where the transformation cannot take place as the hospital is having many defaults including inadequate leadership. The provision of low-quality services is an indication that the failure of the management. According to an article on the united nation convection, in the giving the right to the disability, it includes the right to people with disability to be free from any form of violence (Laing, J. (2017). This acts as a restriction on the means the health care officers to maintain a healthy environment where they don’t use force for the treatment and rehabilitation of people with disabilities. The act controls the facility's functioning but failed to restrict the activities in the hospital indicating failures to other bodies.
The challenges for the implementation of the program were attained through reinforcing the management of the hospital where the manager is to take full responsibility for the facility. The management will in return control the services, quality of services they offer which will make them hire high qualification professionals thus improving the services and enhancing the transformation (Wang, et al. 2020). In return, the service user gets good services that help in their rehabilitation and thus get the services from home where they effectively recover. The health care workers take the specialized role in moving around while checking the condition of the patients and progressing their medication. This transformation will reduce the workload as the nurses will serve a given number of patients reducing the workload for them.
Chapter 4 ConclusionThe transformation policy will help in rendering the services of the patients by the health workers making their treatment and recovery fast. This in return will reduce the time they spend in the hospital for medication helping in the program implementation. Making the program effective will reduce the cases of discrimination and biting experienced by the patients in winterbourne making the program more conducive for the patients and the service providers the process easier and effective. Changing or having a good manager in the hospitals will in return improve and control the quality and treatment of the patient by the health care workers. Also, the coordination of the factors associated with the health centers will help in improving the services to the patients as well as making their recovery faster.
Chapter 5 RecommendationsThe policy must put into place all the measures essential for the transformation where all the funds required are provided to avoid the delay in the implementation.
The policy should also provide specialized health care officials to cater to the need arising from the transformation starting from the training institution for future references.
Reference
Alderwick, H., & Ham, C. (2017). Sustainability and transformation plans for the NHS in England: what do they say and what happens next?. Bmj, 356.
Arnetz, J., Hamblin, L. E., Sudan, S., & Arnetz, B. (2018). Organizational determinants of workplace violence against hospital workers. Journal of occupational and environmental medicine, 60(8), 693.
Barnoux, M. (2019). Community services and transforming care: reflections and considerations. Tizard Learning Disability Review.
Berghout, M. A., Fabbricotti, I. N., Buljac-Samardžić, M., & Hilders, C. G. (2017). Medical leaders or masters?—A systematic review of medical leadership in hospital settings. PloS one, 12(9), e0184522.
Burke, D., Godbole, P., & Cash, A. (Eds.). (2019). Hospital transformation: From failure to success and beyond. Springer.
Chester, V., Devapriam, J., Alexander, R. T., Atkinson, D., Beebee, J., Cross, G., ... & Kitchen, D. (2018). Restrictive Interventions in Inpatient Intellectual Disability Services: How to Record, Monitor and Regulate.
Fylan, B., Marques, I., Ismail, H., Breen, L., Gardner, P., Armitage, G., & Blenkinsopp, A. (2019). Gaps, traps, bridges and props: a mixed-methods study of resilience in the medicines management system for patients with heart failure at hospital discharge. BMJ open, 9(2), e023440.
Fyson, R., & Patterson, A. (2020). Staff understandings of abuse and poor practice in residential settings for adults with intellectual disabilities. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 33(3), 354-363.
Gabutti, I., Mascia, D., & Cicchetti, A. (2017). Exploring “patient-centered” hospitals: a systematic review to understand change. BMC health services research, 17(1), 1-16.
Joyce, T. (2020). Challenging behaviour, inpatient services and governance in England. Tizard Learning Disability Review.
Keasberry, J., Scott, I. A., Sullivan, C., Staib, A., & Ashby, R. (2018). Going digital: a narrative overview of the clinical and organisational impacts of eHealth technologies in hospital practice. Australian Health Review, 41(6), 646-664.
Knight, S. R., Ho, A., Pius, R., Buchan, I., Carson, G., Drake, T. M., ... & Harrison, E. M. (2020). Risk stratification of patients admitted to hospital with covid-19 using the ISARIC WHO Clinical Characterisation Protocol: development and validation of the 4C Mortality Score. bmj, 370.
Laing, J. (2017). Preventing violence, exploitation and abuse of persons with mental disabilities: exploring the monitoring implications of Article 16 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. International journal of law and psychiatry, 53, 27-38.
Newman, L., Harris, V., Evans, L. J., & Beck, A. (2018). Factors associated with length of stay in psychiatric inpatient services in London, UK. Psychiatric Quarterly, 89(1), 33-43.
Okuyama, J. H. H., Galvao, T. F., & Silva, M. T. (2018). Healthcare professional’s perception of patient safety measured by the hospital survey on patient safety culture: a systematic review and meta-analysis. The Scientific World Journal, 2018.
Piroozi, B., Rashidian, A., Moradi, G., Takian, A., Ghasri, H., & Ghadimi, T. (2017). Out-of-pocket and informal payment before and after the health transformation plan in Iran: evidence from hospitals located in Kurdistan, Iran. International journal of health policy and management, 6(10), 573.
Roy, J., Adhikary, K., Kar, S., & Pamucar, D. (2018). A rough strength relational DEMATEL model for analysing the key success factors of hospital service quality. Decision Making: Applications in Management and Engineering, 1(1), 121-142.
Savino, J. A., & Latifi, R. (2019). Hospital and Healthcare Transformation over Last Few Decades. In The Modern Hospital (pp. 23-29). Springer, Cham.
Sinclair, N. (2018). Transforming care: problems and possible solutions. Tizard Learning Disability Review.
Taylor, J. L. (2019). Delivering the Transforming Care programme: a case of smoke and mirrors?. BJPsych bulletin, 43(5), 201-203.
Taylor, J. L., McKinnon, I., Thorpe, I., & Gillmer, B. T. (2017). The impact of transforming care on the care and safety of patients with intellectual disabilities and forensic needs. BJPsych bulletin, 41(4), 205-208.
Taylor, J. L., McKinnon, I., Thorpe, I., & Gillmer, B. T. (2017). The impact of transforming care on the care and safety of patients with intellectual disabilities and forensic needs. BJPsych bulletin, 41(4), 205-208.
Taylor, J. L., McKinnon, I., Thorpe, I., & Gillmer, B. T. (2017). The impact of transforming care on the care and safety of patients with intellectual disabilities and forensic needs. BJPsych bulletin, 41(4), 205-208.
Taylor, J. L., McKinnon, I., Thorpe, I., & Gillmer, B. T. (2017). The impact of transforming care on the care and safety of patients with intellectual disabilities and forensic needs. BJPsych bulletin, 41(4), 205-208.
Usak, M., Kubiatko, M., Shabbir, M. S., Viktorovna Dudnik, O., Jermsittiparsert, K., & Rajabion, L. (2020). Health care service delivery based on the Internet of things: A systematic and comprehensive study. International Journal of Communication Systems, 33(2), e4179.
Wang, J., Okoli, C. T., He, H., Feng, F., Li, J., Zhuang, L., & Lin, M. (2020). Factors associated with compassion satisfaction, burnout, and secondary traumatic stress among Chinese nurses in tertiary hospitals: A cross-sectional study. International journal of nursing studies, 102, 103472.
Washington, F., Bull, S., & Woodrow, C. (2019). The Transforming Care agenda: admissions and discharges in two English learning disability assessment and treatment units. Tizard Learning Disability Review.
Wibowo, T. S., & Mochklas, M. (2020). Urgency Of Organizational Citizenship Behavior Towards Performance Of Nurses Of Type-C Hospitals In Surabaya. International Journal of Scientific & Technology Research, 9(2), 4534-4538.
Williams, P. A., Lovelock, B., Cabarrus, T., & Harvey, M. (2019). Improving digital hospital transformation: development of an outcomes-based infrastructure maturity assessment framework. JMIR medical informatics, 7(1), e12465.
Xing, Y., Liu, Y., & Lattemann, C. (2018). Institutional logics and social enterprises: Entry mode choices of foreign hospitals in China. Journal of World Business, 100974.